Monday 25 February 2013

Sanger et al (2011) notes


Sanger, Lindenberger, Muller (2011)
Interactive brains, social minds
Communicative & Integrative Biology

P 655  difficult ' studying the complexities of social interaction in tightly controlled experimental settings' p 661 'real-life social interactions are spontaneous, reciprocal , and multimodal, and thereby pose great challenges to experimental design and the ability to draw causal inferences'

Definitions

Social cognition ' the mechanism that allows us to understand others '
Mentalizing , theory of mind ' the ability to represent other people's mental states (Frith & Frith (2002) as well as the knowledge needed for interaction and formation of social relationships

Social interaction is more narrowly defined 'turn taking among active, autonomous agents who follow social rules and control their action and reactions according to. Their perceptions'

Joint action ' any form of coordinated action bringing about change'

Coordination ' non accidental correlation between the behaviours of two or more systems that are in sustained coupling, or have been coupled in the past, or have been coupled to another, common system'

Interpersonal action coordination  occurs in ' the context of joint actions and coordination' note synchronisation of speech and movements does not qualify. '

Interpersonal action coordination
Discussed in terms of musicians and dancers but could apply to collaborative learning, especially face-to-face.
'interpersonal action coordination requires the perception,representation and anticipation of one's own and  partner actions'
Joint goal, (task) required. The task determines individual intentions (which may be very different especially in learning contexts)

Investigating the neural basis of social interaction

P 656 'Currently little is known about the brain areas that are involved and the neural mechanisms that implements interpersonally coordinated behaviour'

Designs and methods

Collectively the following  implicate fronto parietal areas

Focus
    Agency
   Cooperation &competition
   Intentional stance
   Self relevance and interpretation of relational stance

Single subjects intact interacting with
   Computers
   Virtual counterparts
   Real counterparts

Methods and techniques involving  EEG
   Formation of shared action representations' (40)
   Movement coordination (41)
   Different forms of action coordination (50,51)

Conclusions and outlook
P 661
' reconcile the dynamics of e phenomenon with the requirements of experimental control'
' there is a need for studies that assess the target behaviour as well as the behavioural cues exchanged between  interaction partners in real time, and relate these measures to neural synchronisation within and between brains' ....  ' Interbrain synchronisation during interpersonal interaction (KRO how important is this online?) coordination clearly depends on multimodal perceptual cues ( e.g. Gestures, facial expressions, movements), but the relation between these cues and Interbrain synchronisation is rarely assessed or analysed'